[update: response from dreamhost CS attached to the end of this post.]
[update: final(?) resolution appended.]
“This is our new mail interface! We love it, you will too! ”
No, I fucking DO NOT love it. But you didn’t ask my opinion as a customer, you told me how you expect me to feel.
I’ve been a happy Dreamhost customer for almost fifteen years. They host many of my domains and many domains that belong to my clients.
Happy until this week, that is. Some clueless fuckwit(s) at Dreamhost had a brilliant idea — let’s pre-filter people’s incoming email in to new IMAP folders WITHOUT ASKING THEIR PERMISSION or even WARNING THEM that this is going to happen. Oh, and if they don’t like it? DON’T GIVE THEM A WAY TO TURN IT OFF.
Yesterday I discovered new IMAP folders on my work account (Mail.app client), “Social” and “Promotion”, and dreamhost is filtering my incoming email into these AND I CANNOT TURN THE FILTERING OFF. Turned on with out my permission and I can’t turn it off. Seriously. So after filing a customer-support ticket they apologize and say they’ll turn it off and that due to customer feedback they’ve turned it off everywhere. If it’s turned off everywhere why did it just get turned on for this account yesterday?
I was wondering why I never noticed this on my personal account (Thunderbird client) and checked my settings. Oh, I’m only showing IMAP folders I’m subscribed to, let me turn that off.
And there they are, as I never subscribed to the Social and Promotion folders. They were added two months ago with mail going in to those folders instead of my inbox. I sorted all that misfiled mail in to folders yesterday and today find even new mail going in to those folders which means they haven’t turned it off and there’s still no way for me to disable it. I’ve deleted the folders after emptying them, maybe that will be similar to turning them off. Assuming they don’t just delete the mail if they can’t find the folder…
Then the unrequested changes to how spam is filtered, making it more difficult for me to manage spam.
It looks like only dreamhost owners can have whitelists/blacklists for spam. “You cannot access this page if you are NOT the DreamHost account owner. If that is the case, please contact the owner or administrator of your DreamHost account and they can modify these settings for you.” Which means I (as the account owner) have to personally update the whitelist for each email account in each domain.
Spam is no longer sortable by its potential spam score. Think about it for two seconds: now to deal with spam I have to go through my entire spam folder and un-spam legit email. Today that’s 1108 messages in one account, and I can’t even list them all on a single page. Instead I get to skim through 50 messages per screen, select-all, then delete. “Select-all, delete” takes a minute and a half (I timed it with a stopwatch). So it will take me half an hour to delete 1108 spam messages.
Can I bill that time to a C-level at dreamhost as I’m not billing it to a customer?
This is the first time I’ve thought about changing hosting/email vendors in a decade. Dreamhost costs more but the service, until now at least, was excellent.
Losing my email with clients and vendors by whimsically filing it for me IS NOT providing a valuable service. If you think it is, let me filter the email of dreamhost C-level execs without their knowledge or permission then make it damned difficult for them to change anything.
Edit 12 Oct, 2016
I filed a ticket about this on 5 Oct. Today, seven days later, someone at dreamhost CS got around to answering the ticket. I’m wondering if the CEO change also involved changes in senior operational staff.
Re: How do I turn off IMAP filtering on the dreamhost side?
Email with CS continued, basically getting canned responses on the newest way to work around spam filtering problems and DH’s aggressive spam filtration. I moved from email to Twitter, thinking maybe it would get bumped to a C-level’s notice instead of just being parked in tickets that were ignored. In mid-January 2017, I received a response from CS that explained things (follows). I also turned off the auto-Junk feature of Thunderbird and Mail.app, it appears that moving mail out of the Spam folder marks it as not-spam, even if it’s moved to “Junk”. It’s still not as accurate as the old system when it comes to marking legit email as spam, I’ve had to whitelist over a 100 domains, including paypal.com, ebay.com, ups.com, dozens of vendors, and several friends. Today I received the weather-related delivery advisory from UPS at three different domain accounts, one of them marked it as junk.
[…] if you want to mark things as spam and not spam, the only way
to do so would be within atmail.”
“Since you are using a separate mail client, best case is to use
whatever spam filtering mechanism it already is using”
“Please allow some time for us to work out all the kinks, but for now
best case is to manage your spam settings within your respective
client, and if you want to mark mail as spam or not spam, you would
need to do so within atmail.”